🏷️ ป้ายกํากับ: topology

We have seen that three spatial dimensions are not just the stage on which physics happens.

They help determine what kinds of physics can happen at all. Change the number of large spatial dimensions, and familiar structures begin to strain. Gravity and electric forces behave differently. Stable orbits become harder to arrange. Atoms and chemistry may lose the reliable bound states they need. Even topology changes: knots, entanglements, and certain kinds of persistent structure belong very naturally to three dimensions.

So the question becomes sharper.

Does this explain why space is three-dimensional?

Or does it only explain why beings like us could only find themselves in a universe where something like three-dimensional space was already in place?

That is a different kind of question. It is not mainly about calculating orbits or atoms anymore. It is about what counts as an explanation.

Two different kinds of answer

There are at least two ways an explanation of three-dimensional space might work.

One would be a physical necessity explanation.

That kind of explanation would say: the deeper laws of reality require exactly three large spatial dimensions. Space is 3D because, at a more fundamental level, it could not have been otherwise. Some hidden principle, symmetry, consistency condition, or deeper theory would force this structure into place.

In schematic form:

deeper law → three large spatial dimensions

A knot feels ordinary because we meet it in ordinary places: shoelaces, cords, thread, rope, hair, fishing line. It feels like a nuisance rather than a deep fact about space.

But a knot is not just “something tangled.”

A real knot is a kind of geometric trap. It is a structure that cannot be undone by ordinary motion. You can pull, twist, stretch, and slide it around, but unless you cut the strand or let it pass through itself, the knot remains.

That raises a quiet question:

Why is a knot possible at all?

The answer depends on something so familiar that it is easy to overlook: we live in three spatial dimensions.

A knot is not just a drawing

In mathematics, a knot is usually thought of as a closed loop sitting in space.

A loose piece of rope with two free ends is not quite the ideal object, because its ends can often be threaded backward through the tangle. A closed loop has no such escape hatch. It is more like a rubber band, a loop of string with its ends joined, or a tiny circular railway that must keep its track continuous.

One compact way to say this is:

\[ \text{a knot is an embedding of } S^1 \text{ in three-dimensional space.} \]

Here \(S^1\) just means a circle: a one-dimensional closed loop. “Embedded” means the loop is placed into space without cutting through itself.

The important part is not the notation. The important part is this:

A knot is a closed loop arranged in space so that it cannot be untangled without cutting the loop or letting it pass through itself.